Comments on: Allama Iqbal’s love life http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108 diary of a concerned Pakistani ! Tue, 22 Jun 2010 04:51:52 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.1 hourly 1 By: Vengeance-is-mine-I-will-repay http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-43244 Vengeance-is-mine-I-will-repay Tue, 15 Jun 2010 07:31:27 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-43244 okay firstly there are several facts in the article but they have been twisted in order to mutilate Allama Iqbal's character. Moreover, his failures in life in no way rule out that he was a poet of intellectual powers that this particular Dr. Sohail cannot really match up to. Also I would like to point out that it is UTTERLY UTTERLY fallacious to the point of being horrendously blasphemous that Iqbal's sister identified with Iqbal's first wife because they had the same name? I don't understand how Dr.Sohail can claim to be a psychiatrist. This would equate Karl Marx and Karl Rove and Mr.Sohail might have expected Rove to identify with Marx, which unfortunately did not happen as history tells us. I would request the blogger to please review the article in depth for it's a poorly written, poorly researched article that relies of sources (Like Atiya Faizi's diary- who has sunk in oblivion but Iqbal stays a star in several cultures and who may like to forge that she had a strong relationship with Iqbal and Iqbal's daughter in law who, God knows how wrote all that she wrote, being intellectually crippled as she was) and then make a value judgment. I am not denying that the article contains some facts, but they have been analyzed through a very objective lens which should be let go of while analyzing a "human being". Please don't fill people up with more propaganda; we already have enough to fill up on courtesy the ten thousand news channels that we already have too much to fill up on. okay firstly there are several facts in the article but they have been twisted in order to mutilate Allama Iqbal’s character. Moreover, his failures in life in no way rule out that he was a poet of intellectual powers that this particular Dr. Sohail cannot really match up to. Also I would like to point out that it is UTTERLY UTTERLY fallacious to the point of being horrendously blasphemous that Iqbal’s sister identified with Iqbal’s first wife because they had the same name? I don’t understand how Dr.Sohail can claim to be a psychiatrist. This would equate Karl Marx and Karl Rove and Mr.Sohail might have expected Rove to identify with Marx, which unfortunately did not happen as history tells us. I would request the blogger to please review the article in depth for it’s a poorly written, poorly researched article that relies of sources (Like Atiya Faizi’s diary- who has sunk in oblivion but Iqbal stays a star in several cultures and who may like to forge that she had a strong relationship with Iqbal and Iqbal’s daughter in law who, God knows how wrote all that she wrote, being intellectually crippled as she was) and then make a value judgment. I am not denying that the article contains some facts, but they have been analyzed through a very objective lens which should be let go of while analyzing a “human being”. Please don’t fill people up with more propaganda; we already have enough to fill up on courtesy the ten thousand news channels that we already have too much to fill up on.

]]> By: zeeshan http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-43148 zeeshan Thu, 04 Mar 2010 18:03:23 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-43148 iqbal was great poet and leader but i am agree with writer because javed iqbal( son of  M iqbal ) also admitterd these fats and he also said that at the last time of my father when i entered the room  i smelled  the alchol  iqbal was great poet and leader but i am agree with writer because javed iqbal( son of  M iqbal ) also admitterd these fats and he also said that at the last time of my father when i entered the room  i smelled  the alchol 

]]> By: Ziad Ahsan http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-43066 Ziad Ahsan Tue, 05 Jan 2010 16:56:56 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-43066 It is all like, Chaand pe thokna ya keecher uchalna. The all emphasis is "How to disgrace". I dont beleive what the author tried us to be convinced but i say What the hell his concern with one's personal life. I am not a student of Iqbaliaat but i studied throughly his whole Urdu poetry and when i compare it to poets n the philosophers of the world, i feel pround enough to fill my chest. Such great man, such great words, such great ideas even sometimes i fail to beleive that a person within us can write so heavenly. I am proud of him, always, if i am sentimental while writing this, it justifies. He is our pride. It is up to you all, my dear freinds, dont go on such propaganda. Just take his books and read. You will be more concerned with what he said, not in what circumstances he lived in his personal life. Iqbal, The Himaliya of the Age It is all like, Chaand pe thokna ya keecher uchalna. The all emphasis is “How to disgrace”. I dont beleive what the author tried us to be convinced but i say What the hell his concern with one’s personal life. I am not a student of Iqbaliaat but i studied throughly his whole Urdu poetry and when i compare it to poets n the philosophers of the world, i feel pround enough to fill my chest. Such great man, such great words, such great ideas even sometimes i fail to beleive that a person within us can write so heavenly. I am proud of him, always, if i am sentimental while writing this, it justifies. He is our pride.

It is up to you all, my dear freinds, dont go on such propaganda. Just take his books and read. You will be more concerned with what he said, not in what circumstances he lived in his personal life.

Iqbal, The Himaliya of the Age

]]> By: king http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-43056 king Tue, 29 Dec 2009 16:27:17 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-43056 its all bull shit written by the writer the writer himself is a psycho patient and chracterless person who made baseless stories against Allama Iqbal and nothing and mr who publised this whole propoganada from where u took this material and how much sure about the validity and reliablity of this content its all bull shit and all bull shit jahan kise ko kuch nahi milta kise kay baray ma to ghar ki kahani sunana shuru kar daitay hain bloddy non sense hell... its all bull shit written by the writer
the writer himself is a psycho patient and chracterless person
who made baseless stories against Allama Iqbal and nothing
and mr who publised this whole propoganada
from where u took this material and how much sure about the validity and reliablity of this content
its all bull shit
and all bull shit jahan kise ko kuch nahi milta kise kay baray ma to ghar ki kahani sunana shuru kar daitay hain
bloddy non sense
hell…

]]> By: SHAHIQ http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-42800 SHAHIQ Tue, 01 Dec 2009 21:00:52 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-42800 Moreover what K.MALIK has said about IQBAL is just propaganda. But for the sake of argument if it is accepted that at some stage of life he had even some of these weaknesses, does it mean that a person can not change in future. The main thing is that what was IQBAL at the end of his life. Otherwise what about HAZRAT OMAR., who at one stage wanted to kill the PROPHET(PBUH) and HAZRAT KHALID who csused great damage to Muslims in GHAZWA-E-UHAD but latter became the GREATEST General of Muslim Army. Does their past overshadow their GREATNESS (Though i believe there is no proof of these allegations about IQBAL during his early life also) Moreover what K.MALIK has said about IQBAL is just propaganda.
But for the sake of argument if it is accepted that at some stage of life he had even some of these weaknesses, does it mean that a person can not change in future. The main thing is that what was IQBAL at the end of his life.
Otherwise what about HAZRAT OMAR., who at one stage wanted to kill the PROPHET(PBUH) and HAZRAT KHALID who csused great damage to Muslims in GHAZWA-E-UHAD but latter became the GREATEST General of Muslim Army. Does their past overshadow their GREATNESS
(Though i believe there is no proof of these allegations about IQBAL during his early life also)

]]> By: SHAHIQ http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-42799 SHAHIQ Tue, 01 Dec 2009 20:59:35 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-42799 Just rubbish and baseless stories. Isnt it funny that the author says, "Courtesy the corrupt text books which the young Pakistanis are bombarded with all their life, a heavenly hero is what every kid is asked to perceive Iqbal as. There is no doubt in the fact that Iqbal was a revolutionary, a great Philosopher and poet but there has been many twists and turns in his personal life which we should all know as well" and after saying that he wants us to believe in whatever BAKWAS he writes. Ok if everything in text books is wrong how could he gurantee that what he is writing is truth. Just rubbish and baseless stories.
Isnt it funny that the author says,
"Courtesy the corrupt text books which the young Pakistanis are bombarded with all their life, a heavenly hero is what every kid is asked to perceive Iqbal as. There is no doubt in the fact that Iqbal was a revolutionary, a great Philosopher and poet but there has been many twists and turns in his personal life which we should all know as well"
and after saying that he wants us to believe in whatever BAKWAS he writes.
Ok if everything in text books is wrong how could he gurantee that what he is writing is truth.

]]> By: Syed Jaafer http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-41120 Syed Jaafer Sat, 14 Nov 2009 21:46:19 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-41120 I think agar kisi k Aib ko chupaya jaye tou zada behtar ha bajaye iske k app usko publicise kerain! I think agar kisi k Aib ko chupaya jaye tou zada behtar ha bajaye iske k app usko publicise kerain!

]]> By: maria kahn http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-40705 maria kahn Tue, 10 Nov 2009 10:51:06 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-40705 it seems that the marital life of great and successful people is always disturbed. it seems that the marital life of great and successful people is always disturbed.

]]> By: khurram http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-40632 khurram Mon, 09 Nov 2009 19:17:09 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-40632 dr,sb used 2 sleep only for 3,4 hours ............... its`nt surprising ? khurram Advocate 03145863665 dr,sb used 2 sleep only for 3,4 hours …………… its`nt surprising ?
khurram Advocate 03145863665

]]> By: Awais http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108&cpage=1#comment-24860 Awais Mon, 13 Jul 2009 18:49:52 +0000 http://blog.ale.com.pk/?p=1108#comment-24860 Iqbal was a great port indeed, a philosopher too (though I won't add great here) but a 'revolutionary'? He belonged to the colonial salaried middle class and his politics was mainly based upon safeguarding the interests of that class. Iqbal was a great port indeed, a philosopher too (though I won't add great here) but a 'revolutionary'? He belonged to the colonial salaried middle class and his politics was mainly based upon safeguarding the interests of that class.

]]>